Coop’s Peanut Butter Sauce

Peanut Butter, Leveled Up

Love a good topping but tired of the jarred stuff that’s mostly mystery oils? Meet the fix. Made from just peanuts and sugar in small batches, this one’s thick enough to hold a spoon steady and loose enough to pour without a fight — no fillers, no fuss. Drizzle it over ice cream, spread it on brownies, dunk your pretzels in it, or dip apple slices straight into the jar. Enjoy it as-is, or give it a quick warm-up for an even deeper, toastier flavor. Bonus points for pairing it with our hot fudge or salted caramel if you’re the type who likes to double up.